The work, while it is still going wrong.

Brightwell

Process posts two or three times a week, the finished thing when it is finished, and a room where members talk to each other.

Process · 16 min

The version I threw away

Three weeks of work, binned, with the reasoning. The failure is the useful part.

Posts

Posts for members

See all posts

Sign in to join the conversation.

Join
StudioCreatorPosts

Process: the version I threw away, and why

Three weeks on this and I have binned the whole second half. Posting the dead version because the reason it failed is more interesting than the fix. Short version: I solved the wrong problem very well. The thing that was actually wrong was the pacing in the first ninety seconds, and no amount of work on the ending was ever going to touch it.

Joon P.Critique

This was posted in a room only members can read.

Members only
Bruno T.The workroom

This was posted in a room only members can read.

Members only
StudioCreatorPosts

Files are up for the last three projects

Studio members: sources, layered files and the presets. Use them for whatever you like including commercial work; a credit is nice and is not required.

Rob A.Off topic

This was posted in a room only members can read.

Members only

Exclusives

The members’ shelf

Everything in the exclusives

How Critique works

Start here4 minMembers only

Read before posting. It is short and it is the reason the room is useful.

Unlock

Behind it

Who makes this

Studio

Creator

Me. I post most days and reply on Mondays.

Ida V.

Moderator

Three years in. Runs Critique when I forget to.

Effie M.

Moderator

Gives the most useful critique on this site.

What you get

Why people join Brightwell

Everything, first

Members see finished work days before it goes anywhere else, and see the versions that came before it.

The process posts

Two or three a week. Sketches, dead ends, the reasoning, and the bits that are embarrassing until they work.

Files and sources

Project files, brushes, presets, stems, templates — whatever the thing was actually made in.

A room, not a comment section

Members talk to each other. It is small and it is moderated and it is the best part.

Monthly hangout

An hour on camera. Half of it is answering things, half of it is working while people watch.

No sponsors

This membership is the whole business model, which is why nothing here has to be safe.

members

Who is already in

9 members. The register is kept for members.

Hangouts

What is coming up

All hangouts
  • 16

    Nov

    Workroom co-working

    Mon, Nov 16, 09:00 AMOnlineMembers only

    Two hours, cameras optional, nobody talks.

  • 20

    Nov

    Monthly hangout

    Fri, Nov 20, 06:00 PMOnlineRecordedMembers only

    An hour on camera. Questions, then work.

  • 4

    Dec

    Open hangout

    Fri, Dec 4, 06:00 PMOnline0/300Open to everyone

    The quarterly one that anyone can come to.

  • 18

    Dec

    Studio reviews

    Fri, Dec 18, 05:00 PMOnline0/8Eight placesMembers only

    Eight pieces of members’ work, looked at properly, in public.

In their words

What members say

Bruno T. · Member, three years
Joon P. · Member
Nour H. · Member

Membership

Pick your tier

Member

Recommended

The process, and the room.

$5/month

  • Every members-only post
  • Work days before anyone else
  • The members’ rooms
  • Monthly hangout, live and recorded

Questions

Two or three times a week for members, plus a public post roughly monthly. Sometimes more when a project is going badly, which is when the posts are best.

Join

Become a member

Process posts, everything first, and the rooms where members talk to each other. Cancel any time.

Free to join. Paid membership from $5/month.

Become a member